Some of goffman s supporters maintained that her sixyear embed with innercity philadelphia youths pushed. Alice goffmans star fell almost as fast as it rose a few years back, as sociologists divided over her controversial book, on the run. Her first book, on the run about the lives of young black men in west philadelphiahas fueled a fight. Alice goffman grew up in philadelphia and attended graduate school at princeton university. As lewiskraus, notes, at the recommendation of her trade publisher, goffman.
The trials of alice goffman by gideon lewiskraus longform. It reveals how the everyday lives of these mentheir loved onesare closely monitored and mined for evidence that is then used against them, exacerbating their alienation and fueling the prisonindustrial complex. On the run offers an ethnographic account based on goffman s work in the fieldand the field happens to be a mixedincome, west philadelphia. She teaches in the sociology department at the university of wisconsinmadison. Apr 19, 2017 gideon lewis kraus is the author of a sense of direction and the kindle single no exit. We suggest participants read the text the trials of alice goffman by gideonlewiskraus and to generally familiarize. The trials of alice goffman her first book, on the run about the lives of young black men in west philadelphia has fueled a fight within sociology over who gets to speak for whom. On the run quotes showing 17 of 7 together, the chapters make the case that historically high imprisonment rates and the intensive policing and surveillance that have accompanied them are transforming poor black neighborhoods into communities of suspects and fugitives. Research conflict over sociologists narrative puts spotlight on ethnography narayan mahon for the chronicle alice goffman s account of a philadelphia neighborhood has set off a debate among. The controversy surrounding alice goffman s on the run is nothing newthe book s appearance was met with both laudatory curiosity and defensive criticism, from within and outside academic sociology. Alice goffman s star fell almost as fast as it rose a few years back, as sociologists divided over her controversial book, on the run. Arrest quotas and hightech surveillance techniques criminalize entire blocks, and transform the very associations that should stabilize young. Fugitive life in an american ghetto was doomed to controversy from the start.
Fugitive life in an american city, an ethnographic account of the fieldwork for her phd dissertation on the impact of mass incarceration and. A brilliant fieldworker and a smart analyst of what she saw and heard, goffman has made a lasting contribution to our understanding of the administration of the law, urban life and race relations, in a book. Among other things, the gideon lewiskraus piece about alice goffman and on the run investigated goffman s extremely implausible multipart claim that. Fugitive life in an american city is one of the major events in sociology of the past few years, earning highprofile praise, criticism, and controversy. Alice goffmans on the run is the best treatment i know of the wretched underside of neoliberal capitalist america. Alice goffman born 1982 is an american sociologist, urban ethnographer, and visiting assistant professor of sociology at pomona college goffman became known because of scholarly controversies concerning her book on the run. Its author, alice goffman, a young sociologist, had an ethnography assignment for an undergraduate class at the university of pennsylvania, and she, the daughter of the renowned sociologist erving goffman 192282, didnt take it lightly. Sociologist alice goffman spent six years in a troubled philadelphia neighborhood and saw firsthand how teenagers of africanamerican and latino backgrounds are funneled down the path to prison sometimes starting with relatively minor infra. Why you should listen as an undergraduate studying sociology at the university of pennsylvania, alice goffman was inspired to write her senior thesis about the lives of the young people living.
Controversy over alice goffman leads pomona students to. On the run is, first and foremost, a remarkable feat of reporting. Goffman became known because of scholarly controversies concerning her book on the run. A sociologists controversial first book and the debate over who gets to speak for whom. In the united states, two institutions guide teenagers on the journey to adulthood. This morning, a couple more pieces were published regarding the growing controversy over alice goffman s muchlauded book on the run. Briefly, the us locks up five on the run is an incredibly authentic look at an emblematic neighborhood in philly where more than half the men at some point have a warrant out for their arrest, causing them to be on the run. Fugitive life in an american city by alice goffman in doc, fb3, rtf download e book. But in the previous months, amid a widening controversy both inside and outside the academy over her research, she and i had. Alice goffman and the problems with rereporting on the. On the run from those who would use their vulnerability to victimize them. All content included on our site, such as text, images, digital downloads and other, is the property of its content suppliers and protected by us and international laws. Fugitive life in an american city fieldwork encounters and discoveries. Gideon lewiskraus new york times magazine jan 2016 25 min permalink.
Nothing illustrates that more forcefully than lewiskrauss article itself, which, for all its ponderous disquisitions on the nature of sociological inquiry, ends up being in substance a contentfree puff piece, designed. In the course of her research, she became roommates with mike and chuck, two friends trying to make ends meet between low wage jobs and the drug trade. One aspect of goffmans book that may be of particular interest to. Alice goffman s on the run has become one of the most controversial books published in sociology in many years. Heres whats in alice goffman s dissertation now gideon lewiskraus weaves all of these complexities together into a really satisfying story in the new york times magazine, explaining the stakes of the controversy in the way only a keen, careful observer one who spent a lot of time thinking it through and hanging out with with the young sociologist at its epicenter can. Forty years in, the war on drugs has done almost nothing to prevent drugs from being sold or used, but it has nonetheless created a littleknown surveillance state in americas most disadvantaged neighborhoods. I first read sociologist alice goffman s book on the run in 2014, before vitriolic gossip accused her of crossing the line from fieldworker to criminal collaborator. She has received numerous awards for her ethnographic work about the sixth street boys of philadelphia and on the run is her first major published work. The book originally published by the university of chicago press, but issued in paperback. Journalist gideon lewiskraus published a longform defense of goffmans book in the new york times magazine, in which he argued that most sociologists. By friday, it looked like her heralded book on fugitives in philly, on the run, was unraveling under increased scrutiny. On the run by alice goffman overdrive rakuten overdrive. The book, an extraordinary firsthand account of the effects of intensive policing on the residents of a black neighborhood in philadelphia, was published in april 2014, on the eve of the black lives matter movement. Alice goffman s fieldwork in a struggling philadelphia neighborhood sheds harsh light on a justice system that creates suspects rather than citizens.
Fugitive life in an american city, an ethnographic account of the fieldwork for her phd dissertation on the impact of mass incarceration and policing on lowincome africanamerican urban communities. Examples of the controversies and accusations related to the book include gideon lewiskrauss the changeling new york times magazine, jan. On the run is rivetinga clearheaded and sobering account of the way it is for too many of the nations young black men who live in the killing fields called american cities. Fugitive life in an american city fieldwork encounters and discoveries goffman, alice on. Fugitive life in an american city, the sociologist alice goffman recounts a heartwrenching story. The object of dispute was goffmans debut book, on the run, which chronicles the. The trials of alice goffman her first book, on the run about the lives of young black men in west philadelphia has fueled a fight. Fugitive life in an american city by alice goffman university of. Aunt pollytoms aunt polly, she isand mary, and the widow douglas is all told about in that book, which is mostly a true book, with some stretchers, as i said before.
Michael apted stumbled into making what has become the most profound documentary series in the history of cinema. Journalist gideon lewiskraus published a long form defense of goffmans book in the new york times magazine, in welke have argued. It is a gripping description of social life of young african american men in one philadelphia neighborhooda aspect of social life about which most americans have limited, if any knowledge. And goffman s ted talk has been viewed more than a million times. Briefly, the us locks up five on the run is an incredibly authentic look at an emblematic neighborhood in philly where more than half the men at some point have a warrant out for their arrest, causing them to be on. Fugitive life in an american city reprint by goffman, alice isbn. Not too long ago, you may recall, the sociologist alice goffmans. Alice goffman born 1982 is an american sociologist, urban ethnographer, and visiting assistant professor of sociology at pomona college goffman is the author of on the run. The new york times magazine on alice goffman the chicago. Alice goffman and the future of ethnography huffpost. Alice goffmans on the run has become one of the most controversial books published in sociology in many years. This is the world behind the statistical sketch alice goffman paints in her preface. On the run tells, in gripping, hardwon detail, what its like to be trapped on the wrong side of the law with no way outthe situation of so many young black americans today.
On the run, we should remember, is alice goffman s first work. Fugitive life in an american city, for which she received widespread praise as well as criticism for an indepth look at overpolicing, poverty, and incarceration experienced by young black men and their families in. It is not easy to write a book about gutwrenching ethnographic experience. Alice goffman was and is a white person of immense social privilege.
Alice goffman spent six years in one philadelphia neighborhood, documenting the routine stops, searches, raids, and beatings that young men navigate as they come of age. Sociologist alice goffman denies murder conspiracy in on. Her moving account of several young black men and their legal entanglements has raised questions about how whites represent blacks in their research, what obligations researchers have to avoid illegal activities of their own, and, most importantly, about the character of truth in. The situation is a product of the united states skyrocketing incarceration ratesin the poor undereducated black neighborhood goffman studies, something like 10% of the young men are incarcerated at any. Fugitive life in an american city fieldwork encounters. Thirtyone yearold alice goffman is an assistant professor at the university of wisconsin. The trials of alice goffman a sociologists controversial first book and the debate over who gets to speak for whom. Goffman is the daughter of erving goffman, considered one of the most influential us sociologists of the twentieth century. Alice goffman s denial of murder conspiracy raises even more questions the sociologist wrote about joining a murder plot. Fugitive life in america is about young africanamerican boys and men on the run from the police in philadelphia.
1050 436 110 1572 1131 971 1445 111 649 1564 326 432 1176 582 103 1115 1388 860 1581 247 527 1106 1324 391 346 791 1036 1315 998 805 638 1394 1430